CIA discovers Ramzi Binalshibh interrogation tapes under a desk
August 17, 2010
AP Exclusive: Terrorist interrogation tapes found
By ADAM GOLDMAN and MATT APUZZO
Associated Press Writers
The CIA has videotapes, after all, of interrogations in a secret overseas prison of admitted 9/11 plotter Ramzi Binalshibh.
Discovered in a box under a desk at the CIA, the tapes could reveal how foreign governments aided the United States in holding and interrogating suspects. And they could complicate U.S. efforts to prosecute Binalshibh, who has been described as one of the "key plot facilitators" in the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.
Apparently the tapes do not show harsh treatment — unlike videos the agency destroyed of the questioning of other suspected terrorists.
The two videotapes and one audiotape are believed to be the only existing recordings made within the clandestine prison system and could offer a revealing glimpse into a four-year global odyssey that ranged from Pakistan to Romania to Guantanamo Bay.
The tapes depict Binalshibh's interrogation sessions in 2002 at a Moroccan-run facility the CIA used near Rabat, several current and former U.S. officials told The Associated Press. They spoke on the condition of anonymity because the videos remain a closely guarded secret.
When the CIA destroyed its cache of 92 videos of two other al-Qaida operatives, Abu Zubaydah and Abd al-Nashiri, being waterboarded in 2005, officials believed they had wiped away all of the agency's interrogation footage. But in 2007, a staff member discovered a box tucked under a desk in the CIA's Counterterrorism Center and pulled out the Binalshibh tapes.
If the tapes surfaced at Binalshibh's trial, they could highlight Morocco's role in a counterterrorism program known as Greystone, which authorized the CIA to hold terrorists in secret prisons and shuttle them to other countries.
The American Civil Liberties Union has asked the government to provide more information about the tapes as part of a long-running lawsuit involving the treatment of detainees.
"Today's report is a stark reminder of how much information the government is still withholding about the Bush administration's interrogation policies," said Alexander Abdo, staff attorney with the ACLU National Security Project.
More significantly to the 38-year-old terror suspect's defense, the tapes also could provide evidence of Binalshibh's mental state within the first months of his capture. In court documents, defense lawyers have been asking for medical records to see whether his years in CIA custody made him mentally unstable. He is being treated for schizophrenia with a potent cocktail of anti-psychotic medications.
With military trial commissions on hold while the Obama administration figures out what to do with a number of terror suspects, Binalshibh has never had a hearing on whether he is mentally fit to stand trial.
"If those tapes exist, they would be extremely relevant," said Thomas A. Durkin, Binalshibh's civilian lawyer.
A Justice Department prosecutor who is already investigating whether destroying the Zubaydah and al-Nashiri tapes was illegal is now also looking into why the Binalshibh tapes were not disclosed.
The CIA first publicly hinted at the existence of the tapes in 2007 in a letter to U.S. District Judge Leonie M. Brinkema in Virginia. The government twice denied having such tapes, recanting once they were discovered. But the government blacked out Binalshibh's name from a public copy of the letter.
At the time, the CIA played down the significance of the videos, saying they were not taken as part of the agency's detention program and did not show CIA interrogations.
But that case can be made only because of the unusual nature of the Moroccan prison, which was largely financed by the CIA but run by Moroccans, the former officials said. The CIA could move detainees in and out, and oversee the interrogations, but officially Morocco had control.
Moroccan government officials did not respond to queries seeking comment on Binalshibh and his time in Morocco. The country has never acknowledged the existence of the detention center.
Morocco has a history of prison abuse and human rights violations. A Moroccan-created commission identified decades of torture, forced disappearances, poor prison conditions and sexual violence. This year's U.S. State Department report on Morocco notes continued accusations of torture by security forces.
Still, current and former officials say no harsh interrogation methods, like the simulated drowning tactic called waterboarding, were used in Morocco. In the CIA's secret network of undisclosed "black prisons," Morocco was described as a way station to hold detainees for a few months at a time.
"The tapes record a guy sitting in a room just answering questions," according to a U.S. official familiar with the program. "They don't show any harsh treatment."
That would make them quite different from the 92 interrogation videos of Zubaydah and al-Nashiri being subjected to waterboarding and other harsh interrogation tactics.
The tapes provide just a snapshot of Binalshibh's journey through CIA black prisons. He was bounced from one undisclosed facility to the next and his story, if it ever comes out at trial, could reveal new details about the CIA prison network. Defense attorneys have described this journey as "a blot on this nation's character."
Intelligence officials maintain the tough tactics saved many lives.
CIA spokesman George Little said: "While we continue to cooperate with inquiries into past counterterrorism practices, the CIA's focus now is exactly where it should be: protecting the American people now and into the future."
Binalshibh belonged to the al-Qaida cell in Hamburg, Germany, that hatched the 9/11 plot. He roomed with Mohammed Atta, who piloted American Airlines Flight 11 into the World Trade Center. Binalshibh tried repeatedly to get a U.S. visa but never succeeded.
The CIA swept him up exactly one year later in Karachi, Pakistan. He was captured with other members of al-Qaida and the young sons of 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, who one former official said had been placed in Binalshibh's care.
Almost immediately, two former CIA officials said, Binalshibh exhibited traces of mental instability that would worsen over time. But others suggest his prolonged detention contributed to that deterioration.
Binalshibh's first stop after his capture was Afghanistan. Shackled and hooded, he was flown on a military plane with a joint CIA-FBI team from Karachi to Bagram. At a spartan CIA facility not far from Bagram, he was manacled to the ceiling and subjected to blaring hard rock music around the clock, according to FBI documents.
When FBI agents finally had a chance to interview Binalshibh, they found him lethargic but physically unharmed. He projected an attitude suggesting he was unconcerned he had been caught.
Before the FBI made any real headway, the CIA flew Binalshibh on Sept. 17, 2002, to Morocco on a Gulfstream jet, according to flight records and interviews.
Current and former officials said this was the period when Binalshibh was taped. His revelations remain classified but the recordings, the officials said, made no mention of the 9/11 plot. It's unclear who made the tapes or how they got to the agency's Langley, Va., headquarters.
In March 2003, Binalshibh was moved to a Polish facility code-named Quartz soon after his mentor, Mohammed, was nabbed in Pakistan. The CIA intentionally paraded Binalshibh past Mohammed. With the two in the same facility, interrogators could quickly check out their stories.
Considered uncooperative by his captors, Binalshibh was put on a liquid diet and subjected to a series of enhanced interrogation techniques, former CIA officials said.
The CIA officials discussed waterboarding him but decided against it. Mohammed endured the harsh technique scores of times.
Binalshibh's interviews became the foundation for parts of the 9/11 commission report, and he provided intelligence about a plot to crash aircraft into London's Heathrow Airport and Canary Wharf, the city's financial center, an official said. The commission report described him and two other men as "key plot facilitators."
With his intelligence value plumbed, Binalshibh was moved with al-Nashiri back to Rabat on June 6, 2003. In September 2003, Binalshibh and at least three other high-value terrorists were secretly flown to the Guantanamo Bay detention camp to prepare for a possible military trial. But they were all taken back to Morocco that spring before the U.S. Supreme Court could grant them access to lawyers.
Back in Rabat, one former official said, Binalshibh put on weight eating the country's carbohydrate-heavy cuisine of couscous and chicken tagine.
From there it was on to Bucharest, Romania, in fall 2004. The facility consisted of six cells, each with a clock and arrow pointing to Mecca. Five other detainees were also housed there, including Mohammed and al-Nashiri.
Binalshibh didn't surface publicly until September 2006, when President George W. Bush announced that he and 13 other top terrorist detainees were being transferred to Guantanamo. The move came after the last remaining secret sites in Romania and Lithuania were closed.
Since his move to Guantanamo, Binalshibh has appeared increasingly erratic. Court records say he has broken cameras in his cell and smeared them with feces.
He has experienced delusions, complaining the CIA was intentionally shaking his bed and cell, according to court records and interviews. He imagined tingling sensations, suspecting things were crawling all over him, and developed a nervous tic, obsessively scratching himself.
Nine years after his capture, there is no indication when Binalshibh and other admitted 9/11 terrorists will face military or civilian trials.
While the tapes could have a bearing on any trial in the future, Binalshibh and other accused 9/11 conspirators have openly admitted their roles, praising the attacks.
Binalshibh and the others have asked to plead guilty, a move that would head off any trial and almost certainly guarantee the videotapes never get played in any court.